The meaning of curriculum-related examination standards in Scotland and England: a home-international comparison

  1. Association of Directors of Education in Scotland (ADES). (2015, 4 August). Directors welcome improving examination performance. Retrieved from
  2. Baird, J. (2000). Are examination standards all in the head? Experiments with examiners’ judgments of standards in A-level examinations. Research in Education, 64, 91–100.
  3. Baird, J. (2007). Alternative conceptions of comparability. In P. E. Newton, J. Baird, H. Goldstein, H. Patrick, & P. Tymms (Eds.), Techniques for monitoring the comparability of examination standards (pp. 124–156). London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
  4. Baird, J. (2010). What constitutes legitimate causal linking? Measurement: Interdisciplinary Research and Perspectives, 8, 151–153. doi:
  5. Baird, J., & Coxell, A. W. (2009). Policy, latent error and systemic examination failures. CADMO, 21, 105–122.
  6. Baird, J., & Eason, S. (2004). Statistical screening procedures to investigate inter-awarding body comparability in GCE, VCE, GCSE, Applied GCSE and GCSE short courses. AQA. 
  7. Baird, J., Cresswell, M. J., & Newton, P. E. (2000). Would the real gold standard please step forward? Research Papers in Education, 15, 213–229.
  8. Baird, J., & Scharaschkin, A. (2002). Is the whole worth more than the sum of the parts? Studies of examiners’ grading of individual papers and candidates’ whole A-level examination performances. Educational Studies, 28, 143–162.
  9. Borsboom, D. (2005). Measuring the mind: Conceptual issues in contemporary psychometrics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  10. Bryce, T., & Humes, W. (2013). The Scottish Qualifications Authority. In T. Bryce, W. Humes, D. Gillies, & A. Kennedy (eds.), Scottish Education: Fourth edition: Referendum. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
  11. Child Poverty Action Group. (2014). Percentage of children living in poverty in Scotland. Retrieved from
  12. Christie, T., & Forrest, G. M. (1981). Defining public examination standards (Schools council research studies). London: Macmillan Education.
  13. Cizek, G. J., & Bunch, M. B. (2007). Standard setting. A guide to establishing and evaluating performance standards on tests. California: Sage.
  14. Coe, R. (1999). Changes in examination grades over time: Is the same worth less? Paper presented at the annual conference of the British Educational Research Association, September 2–5. Brighton: University of Sussex.
  15. Coe, R. (2007a). Common examinee methods. In P. E. Newton, J. Baird, H. Goldstein, H. Patrick, & P. Tymms (Eds.), Techniques for monitoring the comparability of examination standards (pp. 331–367). London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
  16. Coe, R. (2007b). Changes in standards at GCSE and A-level: Evidence from ALIS and YELLIS (Report for the Office for National Statistics, April). Retrieved from
  17. Coe, R. (2010). Understanding comparability of examination standards. Research Papers in Education25, 271–284.
  18. Cresswell, M. J. (1996). Defining, setting and maintaining standards in curriculum-embedded examinations: Judgemental and statistical approaches. In H. Goldstein & T. Lewis (Eds.), Assessment: Problems, developments and statistical issues (pp. 57–84). Chichester: John Wiley.
  19. Cresswell, M. J. (1997). Examining judgments: Theory and practice of awarding public examination grades. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of London Institute of Education.
  20. Cresswell, M. J. (2003). Heaps, prototypes and ethics: The consequences of using judgements of student performance to set examination standards in a time of change. London: Institute of Education.
  21. Creswell, J. W., & Miller, D. L. (2000). Determining validity in qualitative inquiry. Theory into Practice, 39, 124–130. doi:
  22. Cronbach, L. & Meehl, P. E. (1955). Construct validity in psychological tests. Psychological Bulletin, 52, 281–302.
  23. Davie, G. (1961 [3rd edn. 2013]). The democratic intellect, Scotland and her universities in the nineteenth century. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
  24. Deloitte & Touche (2000). Scottish Executive. Retrieved from
  25. Educational Institute of Scotland (2015) Scottish Exam Results – Pupils and Teachers should be praised. Retrieved from
  26. Elliot, D., & Ganson, H. (1999). SEB findings on Scottish achievements. In Scottish Education. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
  27. Elliott, G. (2011). 100 years of controversy over standards: An enduring problem. Research Matters. Special Issue 2: Comparability, 3–8.
  28. Finn, M. E. (1983). Social efficiency progressivism and secondary education in Scotland, 1885–1905. In W. Humes & H. M. Paterson (Eds.), Scottish culture and Scottish education (pp. 175–196). Edinburgh: John Donald.
  29. Forster, M. (2005). Can examiners successfully distinguish between scripts that vary by only a small range on marks? Unpublished internal paper. Cambridge: Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations.
  30. Gray, J., McPherson, A. F., & Raffe, D. (1983). Reconstructions of secondary education: Theory, myth and practice since the War. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
  31. Hayward, L. (2007). Curriculum, pedagogies and assessment in Scotland: The quest for social justice. 'Ah kent yir faither'. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 14, 251–268.
  32. Hayward, L. (2015). Assessment is Learning: The preposition vanishes. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 22, 27–43.
  33. Hayward, L., & Hutchison, C. (2013). ‘Exactly what do you mean by consistency?’ Exploring concepts of consistency and standards in Curriculum for Excellence in Scotland. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 20, 53–68.
  34. HEFCE. (2015). Young participation in higher education. A-levels and similar qualifications. Higher Education Funding Council for England.
  35. House of Commons Education Committee. (2012). The administration of examinations for 15–19 year olds in England. First Report of Session 2012–2013. Volume 1.
  36. Humes, W. (2013). Policy making in Scottish education. In T. Bryce et al. (eds.), Scottish Education: Fourth edition: Referendum (pp. 98–108). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
  37. Humes, W., & Bryce, T. (2013). The distinctiveness of Scottish education. In T. Bryce et al. (eds.), Scottish Education: Fourth edition: Referendum (pp. 138–152). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
  38. Knox, J. (1561). The first book of discipline. Presbyterian Heritage Publications. Retrieved from:
  39. McPherson, H. M. (1983). An angel on the geist: Persistence and change in the Scottish educational tradition. In W. Humes & H. M. Paterson (Eds.), Scottish culture and Scottish education (pp. 216–243). Edinburgh: John Donald.
  40. McVittie, J. (2008). National qualifications: A short history. SQA Policy and New Products Research Report 3. Retrieved from
  41. Newton, P. E. (1997a). Examining standards over time. Research Papers in Education, 12, 227–248.
  42. Newton, P. E. (1997b). Measuring comparability of standards between subjects: Why our statistical techniques do not make the grade. British Educational Research Journal, 23, 433–449.
  43. Newton, P. E. (2003). Contrasting definitions of comparability. Paper presented at the QCA Standards and Comparability Seminar, April 3–4, Milton Keynes.
  44. Newton, P. E. (2005). Examination standards and the limits of linking. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 12, 105–123.
  45. Newton, P. E. (2010a). Contrasting conceptions of comparability. Research Papers in Education, 25, 285–292.
  46. Newton, P. E. (2010b). Thinking about linking. Measurement: Interdisciplinary Research and Perspectives8, 38–56.
  47. Newton, P. E. (2011). A level pass rates and the enduring myth of norm-referencing. Research Matters. Special Issue 2: Comparability, 20–23.
  48. Newton, P. E., Baird, J., Goldstein, H., Patrick, H., & Tymms, P. (2007). Techniques for monitoring the comparability of examination standards. London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
  49. OECD. (2007, 11 December). Reviews of national policies for education: Quality and equity of schooling in Scotland. Paris: OECD. Retrieved from
  50. Ofqual. (2011, May). GCSE, GCE, principal learning and project code of practice. Retrieved from
  51. Ofqual. (2014). Setting GCSE, AS and A Level grade standards in summer 2014 and 2015. Ofqual/15/5759. Retrieved from
  52. Ofqual. (2015). Consultation on: Improving Reviews and Appeals of GCSE, AS and A level Marking; Withdrawing the GCSE, GCE, Principal Learning and Project Code of Practice; New Requirement on Setting BCSE, AS and A level Grade Boundaries. Ofqual/15/5807. Retrieved from
  53. Paterson, H. M. (1983). Incubus and ideology: The development of secondary schooling in Scotland. In W. Humes & H. M. Paterson (Eds.), Scottish culture and Scottish education (pp. 1900–1939). Edinburgh: John Donald.
  54. Paterson, L. (2003). Scottish education in the twentieth century. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
  55. Paterson, L., & Iannelli, C. (2007). Social class and educational attainment: A comparative study of England, Wales and Scotland. Sociology of Education, 80, 330–358.
  56. Philip, H. L. (1992). The higher tradition: A history of public examinations in Scottish schools and how they influenced the development of secondary education. Dalkeith: Scottish Examinination Board.
  57. Popham, J. (Ed.). (1971). Criterion-referenced measurement. An introduction. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Educational Technology Publications.
  58. Raffe, D. (2007). Learning from home–international comparisons: 14–19 policy across the United Kingdom. In D. Raffe, & K. Spours, Policy-making and policy learning in 14–19 education (pp. 133–156). London Bedford Way Papers.
  59. Robin, G. (2014). University of Glasgow Curriculum for Excellence statement. University of Glasgow. Retrieved from
  60. Royal Society of Chemistry. (2008, November). The five-decade challenge. A wake-up call for UK Science Education? Retrieved from
  61. The Scotsman. (2015, 4 August). Attainment gap fears over new and old Higher exams. The Scotsman online. Retrieved from
  62. Scottish Executive. (2003). Educating for excellence: Choice and opportunity. The Executive’s Response to the National Debate. Edinburgh. Retrieved from
  63. Scottish Executive. (2004). A Curriculum for Excellence. Edinburgh. Retrieved from
  64. Scottish Executive. (2008). A consultation on the next generation of national qualifications in Scotland. Edinburgh. Retrieved from
  65. The Scottish Government. (2014). Poverty and income inequality in Scotland: 2012/13. National Statistics Publication. Retrieved from
  66. The Scottish Government. (2015a, June). A draft national improvement framework for Scottish education. Retrieved from
  67. The Scottish Government. (2015b, June). High level summary statistics. School education. Retrieved from
  68. The Scottish Government. (2015c). Attainment and leaver destinations supplementary data. Retrieved from
  69. The Scottish Government. (2015d). Results day for students. Retrieved from
  70. The Scottish Office. (1994). Higher still: Opportunity for all. Edinburgh: HMSO.
  71. Scottish Parliament. (2015a). Official report: Meeting of the Parliament 28 May 2015. Scottish Parliament. Retrieved from
  72. Scottish Parliament. (2015b). Education and Culture Committee 22 September 2015. Retrieved from
  73. Scottish Qualifications Authority. (2005) The Scottish Standard: a Guide to Pass Mark Meetings for National Courses. Retrieved from
  74. Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA). (2013). Assessment in the new national courses and units. Retrieved from
  75. Scottish Qualifications Authority. (2014). SQA Awarding Body Code of Practice. Publication Code: FA6723.
  76. Scottish Qualifications Authority. (2015a). Results for national courses and awards. Retrieved from
  77. Scottish Qualifications Authority. (2015b). A guide to grade boundary setting. Retrieved from
  78. Scottish Qualifications Authority. (u.d.). Design principles for national courses. Retrieved from
  79. Scharaschkin, A., & Baird, J. (2000). The effects of consistency of performance on A level examiners’ judgements of standards. British Educational Research Journal, 26, 343–357.
  80. Sikes, P., & Potts, A. (2008). Researching education from the inside. Investigations from within. Abingdon: Routledge.
  81. Social Mobility and Child Poverty Commission. (2014, October). State of the Nation 2014: Social mobility and child poverty in Great Britain. Presented to Parliament pursuant to section 8B(6) of the Child Poverty Act 2010.
  82. The Telegraph. (2015a, 4 August). Questions over higher Scottish exam pass rate. The Telegraph online. Retrieved from
  83. The Telegraph. (2015b, 9 October). Can you answer the tricky crocodile maths question, that left students ‘in tears’. The Telegraph online. Retrieved from
  84. Warmington, P., & Murphy, R. (2004). Could do better? Media depictions of UK educational assessment results. Journal of Education Policy, 19, 285–299.
  85. Wiliam, D. (1996). Standards in examinations: A matter of trust? The Curriculum Journal, 7, 293–306.